Behaviourally Anchored Rating Scale (BARS)

A behaviourally anchored rating scale (BARS) is a performance rating method where each point on the scale is described by a specific example of behaviour, rather than a vague label like "good" or "excellent". For a competency such as customer service, a 1 might be "argues with customers about policy" and a 5 "anticipates the customer's next issue and solves it before they ask". Anchoring ratings to observable behaviour makes them more consistent across managers and easier to explain.

Also known as: BARS, behaviorally anchored rating scale, behavioural rating scale, BARS method of performance appraisal

Reviewed

Key takeaways

  • BARS describes each rating level with a concrete example of behaviour.
  • It reduces vague, inconsistent ratings because everyone uses the same anchors.
  • It takes time to build, since anchors must come from real examples in each role.
  • It works best for a small number of core competencies, not every task.
BARS ties each rating to a specific, observable behaviour, so a '4' means the same thing for every manager.

At a glance

What it is
A rating scale with a behaviour example at each level
Typical scale
5 to 7 points per competency
Main benefit
More consistent, explainable ratings
Related
Competency framework, performance review bias, calibration

Why does BARS matter?

Most rating scales use labels such as "meets expectations" that each manager interprets differently. That is a major source of performance review bias. BARS replaces interpretation with shared examples, so two managers looking at the same work are more likely to give the same rating. Patricia Smith and Lorne Kendall introduced the method in 1963 to make ratings more reliable.

BARS example

Competency: Collaboration (5-point scale)

RatingBehavioural anchor
5Brings other teams in early, resolves conflicts between groups and shares credit for joint wins
4Proactively shares information and offers help to colleagues on other projects
3Responds to requests from teammates promptly and keeps others informed
2Shares information only when asked; sometimes misses commitments to others
1Withholds information or blames others when joint work goes wrong

How do you build a BARS?

  1. Pick the competencies that matter most for the role, ideally from your competency framework.
  2. Collect critical incidents: real examples of excellent and poor behaviour from managers and high performers.
  3. Sort the examples into the competencies they describe.
  4. Have a panel rate each example on the scale, and keep the ones with strong agreement.
  5. Write the final anchors, one or two per level.
  6. Test with real reviews and refine.

Pros and cons of BARS

ProsCons
More consistent ratings across managersTime-consuming to build for each role
Clear, observable expectations for employeesNeeds updating as roles change
Easier to explain and defend ratingsReal behaviour may not match any anchor exactly
Reduces halo, leniency and central tendencyWorks less well for highly varied or creative roles

Worked example

A support team's managers rate "customer focus" very differently: one gives everyone 4s, another mostly 2s. HR runs a workshop where each manager brings three real examples of great and poor customer handling. The group writes five anchors from those examples. In the next cycle, ratings across the two managers' teams move much closer, and employees say they finally understand what a 5 looks like.

Frequently asked questions

What is a behaviorally anchored rating scale?
A rating method where each level on the scale is described by a specific example of on-the-job behaviour, making ratings more objective.
What is an example of BARS?
For "communication", a 5 might be "explains complex trade-offs clearly to senior leaders and adjusts to the audience" and a 1 "sends updates that leave stakeholders unsure of next steps".
What are the advantages of BARS?
Ratings are more consistent across managers, expectations are clearer, and reviews are easier to explain because they rest on behaviour.
What are the disadvantages of BARS?
It takes time and expertise to create and maintain, and it is harder to apply to roles where good work looks very different from case to case.
How is BARS different from a graphic rating scale?
A graphic rating scale uses labels or numbers alone (such as 1 to 5, "poor" to "excellent"). BARS adds a description of behaviour to each level.
Who created BARS?
Patricia Cain Smith and Lorne Kendall introduced the method in a 1963 paper in the *Journal of Applied Psychology*.

Sources

  • Patricia C. Smith and L. M. Kendall, "Retranslation of expectations", *Journal of Applied Psychology* (1963)

See it in practice

Compare performance review software

Related reading

Related terms

All glossary terms

One culture-first performance system

Generated in minutes. Owned by you.

The Sageo team, together