---
title: "Peer Feedback"
description: "Peer feedback is input colleagues give each other on their work. See why it matters, example questions and comments, and how to collect it fairly."
url: "https://sageo.ai/glossary/peer-feedback"
source: "Sageo (sageo.ai)"
---


# Peer Feedback

Peer feedback is input that colleagues at a similar level give each other about their work, collaboration and impact. It can be informal and ongoing, or collected formally as part of a performance review or 360-degree feedback cycle. Peers often see day-to-day work that managers miss, so their view adds detail and balance to a review. Good peer feedback is specific, balanced and focused on behaviour, not personality.

**Also known as:** peer review (at work), peer evaluation, colleague feedback, peer-to-peer feedback

## Key takeaways

- Peer feedback comes from colleagues who work alongside someone, not their manager.
- It fills in what managers do not see, especially collaboration and day-to-day work.
- Ask 3 to 5 focused questions rather than a long form.
- Use it to inform reviews, not as a popularity vote.

## At a glance

- **Who gives it:** Colleagues at a similar level who work with the person
- **When:** Ongoing, and during review or 360 cycles
- **Best format:** 3 to 5 open questions with specific examples
- **Related:** 360-degree feedback, upward feedback, SBI feedback model

## Why does peer feedback matter?

Managers see only part of someone's work. Peers see how they collaborate, share knowledge, handle pressure and help others succeed. Including peer input makes reviews fairer and reduces the impact of one manager's biases. Giving and receiving feedback between colleagues also builds a culture where problems are raised early instead of saved for review season.

## Peer feedback questions

1. What is one thing this person does that makes the team more effective?
2. What is one thing they could do differently to have more impact?
3. Describe a time they helped you or the team succeed.
4. How do they handle disagreement or difficult conversations?
5. What should they keep doing, start doing and stop doing?

## Peer feedback examples

**Positive:** "In the Q3 migration, Lina wrote the runbook before anyone asked and walked three of us through it. We finished a day early with no incidents."

**Constructive:** "In planning meetings, Arjun often commits the team to dates before checking capacity. Twice this quarter we had to push back on stakeholders afterwards. It would help if he checked with us first."

## How do you collect peer feedback fairly?

1. **Let the employee and manager choose reviewers together**, from people who worked closely with them.
2. **Ask 3 to 5 peers**, enough to see patterns.
3. **Ask for examples**, not ratings alone; the SBI model helps.
4. **Decide on anonymity** up front and explain it; many teams use confidential feedback shared through the manager.
5. **Look for themes** across reviewers rather than reacting to one comment.
6. **Train people** to give feedback that is specific and kind.

## Worked example

For her mid-year review, a product manager nominates five peers. Four mention her clear written specs; three say she is hard to reach during release weeks. Her manager shares both themes. Together they agree she will hold a 15-minute daily open slot during releases. At the end-of-year review, two of the same peers mention the change as a positive.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is peer feedback?

Feedback colleagues give each other on their work and behaviour, either informally or as part of a structured review.

### Should peer feedback be anonymous?

It depends on your culture. Anonymous feedback can be more candid but harder to act on. Many teams use confidential feedback, where the manager knows who said what but shares themes.

### How many peers should give feedback?

Three to five is common. Fewer than three makes it hard to spot patterns and protect confidentiality.

### What is the difference between peer feedback and 360 feedback?

Peer feedback comes only from colleagues. 360 feedback combines input from peers, the manager, direct reports and sometimes customers.

### Should peer feedback affect ratings?

It should inform them, alongside the manager's evidence and self-assessment. It should not be used as a vote that decides the rating.

### How do you give constructive peer feedback?

Describe a specific situation and behaviour, explain the impact, and suggest what would help, using a model such as SBI.

## Sources

- Center for Creative Leadership, Situation-Behavior-Impact (SBI) feedback model (ccl.org)
